The Chess Variant Pages
Custom Search




[ Help | Earliest Comments | Latest Comments ]
[ List All Subjects of Discussion | Create New Subject of Discussion ]
[ List Latest Comments Only For Pages | Games | Rated Pages | Rated Games | Subjects of Discussion ]

Comments/Ratings for a Single Item

Later Reverse Order Earlier
This item is a game information page
It belongs to categories: Orthodox chess, 
It was last modified on: 2001-10-05
 Author: Hans L. Bodlaender. Almost chess. One queen has combined rook and knight moves. (8x8, Cells: 64) [All Comments] [Add Comment or Rating]
Fergus Duniho wrote on 2018-08-03 UTC

I plan on removing the scripts for creating FFEN diagrams once they are all converted to single images with the Diagram Designer. I have already removed the scripts for FFEN Xiangqi diagrams.


Ben Reiniger wrote on 2018-08-02 UTC

I came across this page and the comments about initial setup.  I agree, and have updated the images.  While I was at it, I changed the first image to use the Diagram Designer.  (I left the second; I guess I have a soft spot for those ffen->diagram scripts.)

For the record, the old diagrams put bishops on file b rather than c.  It may be worth mentioning, that setup does guard the vulnerable c pawns, so it might be a worthwhile alternative setup, if same-color bishops don't bother you or if you adopt a bishop conversion rule.


Gary Gifford wrote on 2007-10-03 UTC
I agree with Matthew Paul's 2004 comment. He stated, 'I think the diagrams are wrong....' Black has two dark-squared bishops and White has two light-squared ones. If it was supposed to be that way I imagine they would have discussed that in the rules.

Joe Joyce wrote on 2007-10-03 UTC
It is interesting that Betza states the Marshall is worth the same as the queen, but when there's only one Marshall on the board, it goes to white. With the Marshall actually being worth fractionally less that the queen, does this arrangement eliminate white's first move advantage? Conversely, if black is the only one to have the Marshall, how does this affect the win-lose ratio? It seems on first glance that white would gain a greater advantage, for knowing the opening lines with a queen, and black would need to figure out a new opening. Does such a result mean the queen is better than the Marshall, or much of anything?

George Duke wrote on 2007-10-03 UTC
In 1994 David Pritchard 'ECV' (Introduction) and in 1995 Ralph Betza email(whether Betza first thought of it or not), Almost Chess is 'radical'. Clearly, we are generally talking two-track about new rules sets. One of our tracks is standard mad-Queen FIDE replacements: Black Ghost, Fischer Random, 'bring back free castling' and a hundred, or even five hundred, others. Probably the 'Car-Caps' belong with this first group even though requiring 8x10. The second track is Chess Variant free-form with anywhere from 10,000 to some countless 10 to the 50th or 100th forms. More interesting right here is 'Sort of Almost Chess', a different armies variate with only one of the Queens as Marshall(RN). That would follow reviewed-lately Black Ghost in creating more-than-usual asymmetry. Presumably, from the brief exchange, RBetza invented SoAC in 1994.

Derek Nalls wrote on 2005-02-13 UTC
[Comment voluntarily deleted.]

Matthew Paul wrote on 2004-08-19 UTC
I think the diagrams are wrong. The Queen's (Marshall's) Knight and Bishop are switched. I don't believe this was the intention, as only the queen is changed.

7 comments displayed

Later Reverse Order Earlier

Permalink to the exact comments currently displayed.